SKINNY: A Novel (P.S.)- By Diana Spechler

On April 25, 2011 by Juliet

Last week, Charlotte @ The Great Fitness Experiment reviewed Skinny: A Novel (P.S.) by Diana Spechler.  After commenting on the post, Ms. Spechler was kind enough to contact me and send me a free copy of the book to review here as well!  I think Charlotte’s review was spot-on, but for those of you who haven’t read it, I will repeat the sentiments here :)

The story is centered around a young, twenty something woman from NYC named Gray and is told/narrated from her perspective.  After the death of her morbidly obese father due to a heart attack, Gray finds herself completely lost (despite their less than stellar relationship) and seeks food for comfort.  When the comfort is not there, this behavior rapidly degenerates, immediately, into binge eating disorder.  In an attempt to absolve a dark family secret, free herself from her binge eating, and seek some answers that have been lost to her, Gray begins working at a fat camp she finds on the internet as a counselor.   It should, furthermore, be noted that the book is loosely based off of Ms. Spechler’s own experiences working as a counselor at a fat camp.

There’s the basic premise of the book.  What did I think?

I really enjoyed and disliked this book at the same time.  Let me elaborate: It is excellently written.  I could not bring myself to put it down and finished it in about 2 days – seriously, I refused to get off the couch and stop reading it all day Saturday.  I disliked it because Ms. Spechler wrote it so well that the way she describes Gray’s fluctuating emotions and battles with self image are difficult to deal with.  At points I related so well to the protagonist that I was forced to be confronted with a lot of emotions I generally keep compartmentalized and forgotten.  That being said, I feel the reasons I “disliked” the book are the same reasons I liked it so much.

While I have fortunately never suffered from an eating disorder, Gray finds herself immersed in a world where what she thinks of herself DIRECTLY correlates with her opinion of her body and all those around her are constantly facing similar issues – which is something I think most women have, sadly, experienced.  On the topic of eating disorders… I should mention that they are a prevalent theme throughout Skinny and ought to be considered before you read it if you are particularly sensitive to the subject.  (Gray herself switches back and forth between binge eating and anorexia to the point of hair loss while her campers battle bulimia.)

Skinny was, once again, a reminder of why I keep this blog, am constantly trying to encourage those around me to be the best they can be, and started bodybuilding in the first place.  Thank you again, Ms. Spechler, for sending me a copy!

CONTEST PREP UPDATES:

  • Next show is less than 2 weeks away, I dropped another pound down to 118.
  • We’re keeping my carbs low but not obscenely so… workout days are 125.  We’ve dropped my fat intake again to 20g a day but I’ve doubled my fatty acid supplement intake.
  • My energy levels are fine but I am starting to mentally burn out – again.  Saturday is my refeed and I took in 35g fat, 225g CHO, and 165g protein and I didn’t even enjoy it.  I just spread the macros out over the day.  It feels like food and eating at this point are just something I do because I have to.  I guess 24 weeks (YUP! I’m in week 24 of this bad boy of a diet) of meticulously portioning and planning every meal kind of sucks the joy out of it.  I don’t really mind though.  To me, the sacrifice is worth it for the show and it’s not like food is going anywhere in the next two weeks.  Corporate America will be sure of that!
  • When I hammer out the details of my transition into the off season, I’ll be sure to write a blog entry about it.
  • http://livethefitlife.wordpress.com Kelsey@LivetheFitLife

    Ahh! That book sounds really great… I’m definitely going to try to pick up a copy once my semester ends next week! We all know that body image issues are VERY prevalent among…well… pretty much everyone!

    I can’t wait to hear about your next show! I can’t imagine having t count macro’s and be so meticulous with diet for that long… I’d be mentally drained too! You’re almost there, though :)

    • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

      It’s definitely a challenge (the diet) but I like challenges so it’s good! I am kind of looking forward to a new challenge of eating “normal” (comparatively to now… still not normal by american standards :P )

  • http://www.truth2beingfit.com Jody – Fit at 53

    This statement: what she thinks of herself DIRECTLY correlates with her opinion of her body

    Man, that hit home & I am sure with many other women out there – media & TV & movies push it! The book sounds amazing & scary all at the same time. Thx for the review!

    • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

      amazing and scary hits the nail on the head! It’s a fantastic (but difficult emotionally) read

  • http://www.healthforthewholeself.com Katie @ Health for the Whole Self

    Thanks for sharing your review of the book! It sounds like I will very much relate to it. I can’t wait to read it!

  • http://www.thefitwriter.wordpress.com Nic at The Fit Writer

    Hey girlfren! I love hearing the nitty gritty of your prep. 20g fat, does that include your EFAs? (I’m guessing not). Know what you mean about feeling meh about food. Sometimes I wish it would prep and cook itself…I love to eat but the thinking about it gets boring! I am actually right now going to write out a ‘menu’ for lifting/rest/cardio/hiit days and try just following that so I don’t have to think about it. We’ll see! :)

    • http://www.followingfit.com Kristen

      Butting in (I, uh, seem to do that a lot) — I pre-plan my entire food day in advance exactly so that I *don’t* have to think about it. That way I think about what I am going to eat once for the whole day (ha ha — or week), and after that, I just eat it and enjoy it. I think it helps.

      • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

        @Nic: Nope, the 20 g doesn’t include my EFAs (thats why i doubled their intake) Good call on writing the menu, let me know how it goes!!

        @ Kristen: I know you’ve seen the pictures of my fridge…. HAH I do the SAME thing. Oh yeah, because we’re the same person. It DEFINITELY helps though. I have found myself far more successful “planning” food instead of “tracking” food if that makes sense?

      • http://www.thefitwriter.wordpress.com Nic at The Fit Writer

        Oh yes so do I, that’s the thinking about it I’m referring to ;) Sometimes it seems there’s no let-up, I guess. I think my plan of using a ‘template’ and repeating it will really help…save time, thought/energy and effort! :)

        Joob – thanks! :)

        • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

          To continue this lil’ comment chat: What do you use to record your food? I use excel so I can just copy and paste things. Its kind of like having a ‘bank’ of food and portions to refer back to. I could talk about this stuff all day – such a nerd.

  • http://squatlikealady.blogspot.com Sable

    Thanks for this review! I think I will be buying this book as a result of your & Charlotte’s reviews =)

    Ugh 24 weeks of contest prep? OUCH. You sure are right though — food is not going anywhere anytime soon. (I watched Food, Inc last night. HIGHLY recommended!)

    • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

      I’ve been meaning to watch that movie!

      And technically I am doing a 25 week cut. I just happen to be in week 24 :) HOME STRETCH

  • http://bookwormlifts.blogspot.com Bookworm

    Hmm, interesting book. Thanks for the review!

    And on the contest front: go, fight, win!!! I’m really excited to hear how it goes.

  • http://www.cuisineats.com chrysta

    Thanks for the book review. Sounds like a really interesting book id like to check out.

    Good luck and congrats on all the contest prep work! that is tough work for sure. Im rooting for you!! =)
    have an awesome day!

  • http://funfoodandfreeweights.wordpress.com Alexandra

    Nice review, I’ll definitely have to consider reading it. Sounds like a really relateable read. Oh and an extreme good luck to ya! All that hard contest prep work is paying off! :)
    Hope you have a great rest fo the week!

  • Amy

    Sounds like an interesting book. I myself have battled anorexia. I now weight train and am trying to gain lean muscle and I’m having such a hard time. I’m eating 2500-2700 calories a day and can’t gain. My hairs falling out bad. I’m 5″4″ and 104 its very scary especially when u think ur doing good and eating enough and ur hairs still falling out and ur not gaining weight. I no longer starve myself or do cardio just weight train. I now what to have muscle definition and be fit and healthy, not skinny. I can relate. May have to read this!

    • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

      Honestly Amy… I would actually recommend you NOT read this book. It is a far cry from a happy-go-lucky ending. If you have a history with eating disorders (and it sounds like a recent history at that) it might be even more difficult for you to handle because it evokes a lot of emotion.

      In regards to your weight training… if you don’t mind my asking, how old are you? I am going to write a bit about this subject I think

      • Amy

        I’m 40 and I cut my weight training from 5 days to 4 afraid I’ll lose more weight.

        • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

          Well you likely won’t lose weight from cutting your training down to 4 days. Perhaps you are even overtraining… I only ever train 4 days a week and I know people who have made great gains on only 3.

          Have you been weight lifting for very long? If this is something that is new to you… know that building muscle is a huge process. It isn’t something that you will see visible gains in a few weeks or months but rather years and years. Jamie Eason is the standard “example” of what strong women look like but she has been weight lifting for 10+ years to look like that. I have been weight training for a year and the single pound of muscle I put on has been dieted off during this contest prep. The best thing you can do is gauge your gains in terms of strength: that’s what I do.

          I am not knowledgeable what-so-ever in the realm of eating disorders…I wish I could offer you some comfort in that arena but know that what you are doing now is right and healthy. You should be very very proud of yourself for that (I know I am proud of you!)

          • Amy

            Thanks so much Juliet, I’ve been weight training for 2 years now and I can honestly say since weight training I have a hard time keeping weight on. I left inpatient eating half as much as now 5 years ago and maintained a healthy weight. since i started to weight train i’ve doubled my calories and still have trouble keeping weight on so all those girls who are afraid weight training will make them big I’m walking proff it burns more calories. I haven’t really gained alot of stregth thats for sure. Thats what concerns me and my hairs falling out bad.

  • http://www.followingfit.com Kristen

    I think I need to read this. I have never battled an eating disorder, but with the other history of “disordered eating” in my family, this might be a relevant read.

    I have to admit that I might not be happy on 20g of fat a day for very long. I needs my PB.

    • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

      truthfully i think it is a better read if you have NOT experienced an eating disorder solely because that means it won’t trigger anything. It is (as I said in an earlier reply) not a happy go lucky kind of book.

      And fortunately I don’t have to! Less than 2 weeks left!

  • http://thegreatfitnessexperiment.blogspot.com charlotte

    So interesting to read your review too! It sounds like we had pretty similar reactions to it! Def. couldn’t put it down either! (And thank you for linking to my review – you are a sweetie!) As for the contest, you are a rockstar in my book already so I have no doubt you will keep on keeping on and rock it!

    • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

      I went back and reread your review after I read the book. My feelings about it were almost spot on with yours! It was a strange combination of being totally immersed and not being able to put it down but being very upset by all the things that happened in it because it evoked a lot emotions.

      And awww…. shucks. Thanks for the encouragement!

  • Pingback: Eggs and split squats! Thank gosh it’s the weekend! « live the fit life

  • http://sneakersandsnacks.wordpress.com kiki

    I want to read this and I don’t. Its hard to explain. It sounds like an amazing read but because I have battled with those issue it will probably touch a nerve. Its on my list if I get up the courage to read it :-)

    • http://heyjoob.wordpress.com Juliet

      I completely understand. TBH, if you are sensitive to those issues being brought up, I would be careful about reading it. I have never battled these things (well body image issues? yes, who hasn’t. disordered eating? no) and it was still a difficult read for me that touched home.

      If you think you can handle it though, it is quite good and very realistic.